People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Such a nice little chill spot. Tried them for the first time today, and omg the pizza is so good! Mr. Gargano was so nice and didn't mind my fanning out over his son [WWE superstar Johnny Gargano]. Also gotta love how early they open up. Definitely a new go to place. ”
“ Still miss you guys. Pizza was twice as good as everyone else for one half the price. Hope to insurance company was fair to you. Best wishes for the future. Enjoy your well deserved rest. ”
“ Amazing food, respectful and kind owners, quick and promised service, if they say 15 minutes for your food they mean it. Clean place, open for eating on the inside, they have a rentable hall of good size, definitely worth the trip and the food is worth the price ”
“ Great place! Good food, great prices, even better service! Ate there every weekday for 3 weeks and never had a bad meal! Jo Anne and Frank are great friendly people! Hope to see them again some day! ”
“ Five stars isn’t enough. Awesome place to go if in the area. Good pizza and for a better price. The owner was very nice and even talked while I was waiting for my pizza. Talked about wrestling and spoke very highly of his son. Will definitely 100% be back and recommend. ”
“ They were extremely friendly and gave me a tour of the facility. Their pizzas are some of the best I have ever had! It is my personal opinion that they be visited by anyone looking for a good pie. You will be accompanied with a smile and an attitude that is so longed for in this world today. I actually dined in and took it home on two different occasions. Below does not give this option so I add it here. ”
“ The best pizza I have ever had in my entire life flavor cheese dough made exactly how it's supposed to be made service was phenomenal staff is super nice and professional. I now live in South Carolina and the only thing I miss about Cleveland Ohio is Gargano's pizza. I will be calling them tomorrow to see if there is a way to get them to mail me a uncooked pizza it is all my kids tall about to this day is the pizza place on West 25th amazing and I recommend this place to any and everyone. It is how pizza is supposed to be made and taste. Miss your pizza and wonderful service. Thank you for the memories you have given my children. They were 3 and 4 years old and are now 8 and 9 and still talk about your pizza. God Bless. ”
“ The customer service is phenomenal and very personable. I'm not from the area but was driving through from a music festival back home. I tried today's special, a three topping 8 slice. The crust had a satisfying crunch. I had mushrooms that tasted so fresh. I was pleasantly surprised to see a dusting of parmesan on the pie. I would definitely recommend and revisit if I find myself in the area again! ”
Menu
Pizza With One Topping
Fish Sandwich
Wings
Wings With Fries
Ribeye Steak Sandwich
About
Coffee A'more & Gargano's Catering
Welcome to Coffee A'more & Gargano's Catering, a beloved dining destination nestled in the heart of Cleveland, Ohio. Located at 3484 W 25th St, Cleveland, OH 44109, this charming eatery is not just a place to grab a bite; it's a culinary haven where exceptional flavors meet warm hospitality.
Coffee A'more & Gargano's Catering has quickly become a local favorite. With a menu brimming with delicious options, it caters to a wide range of tastes, from the classic Pizza with One Topping to the bold flavors of their Wings, available in a variety of sauces. Whether you're in the mood for a satisfying Double Cheeseburger or a refreshing Garden Salad, there's something here to please every palate.
- Popular Items:
- Pizza with One Topping: A must-try, known for its flavorful crust and generous toppings.
- Onion Rings: Golden-brown crispy slices that provide the perfect crunch.
- Anti Pasta Salad: An enticing mix of chopped cured meats, fresh cheeses, and briny olives that transports you straight to Italy.
- Italian Sub: A classic filled with layers of ham, salami, capicola, and cheese, a true delight for sandwich lovers.
The reviews speak volumes about the inviting atmosphere and friendly service. Customers rave about the welcoming vibe, with many noting the kindness of the owners, Jo Anne and Frank. One patron remarked on their experience waiting for pizza while sharing a conversation about wrestling with Frank, who proudly spoke of his son, WWE superstar Johnny Gargano. This personal touch sets Coffee A'more apart, making every visit feel special.
What truly makes this establishment shine is its commitment to quality. Their French Fries are deeply fried to golden perfection, while the Chef Salad bursts with freshness. And let’s not forget the Breaded Mushrooms, which promise a delightful crunch in every bite.
With ample seating and rentable hall space, Coffee A'more & Gargano's Catering is perfect for casual meals or larger gatherings. It's a place you can quickly turn into a regular stop, as customers find themselves coming back day after day, all to savor the remarkable meals at unbeatable prices.
Next time you’re in the Cleveland area, do yourself a favor and stop by Coffee A'more & Gargano's Catering. Your taste buds will thank you, and who knows—you may just find yourself in a warm conversation with the family behind the fare. Trust me, this is a culinary experience you won't want to miss!
Book a table